What Is the Difference Between a CT Scan and an MRI for the Heart?
The main difference between a CT scan and an MRI for the heart is what each one is best at showing. A cardiac CT scan uses X-rays to produce detailed pictures of the coronary arteries, so it is the scan of choice for checking for narrowing or fatty plaque that could cause angina or a heart attack. A cardiac MRI uses a powerful magnet and radio waves, with no X-rays, to show the heart muscle, chambers and valves in fine detail, so it is better for questions about damage, inflammation or thickening of the heart muscle itself.
CT is quick, usually taking 10 to 20 minutes in the scanner, but involves a low dose of radiation. MRI involves no ionising radiation but takes longer, often 15 to 90 minutes, and can feel noisy and enclosed. Which one you need depends on the question your cardiologist is trying to answer, and many people never need an MRI at all.
Cardiac CT vs MRI at a glance
Cardiac CT | Cardiac MRI | |
How it works | X-rays and a computer build cross-sectional images | A strong magnet and radio waves build detailed images |
Best at showing | Coronary arteries, plaque and calcium | Heart muscle, chamber size, pumping and scarring |
Typical scan time | About 10 to 20 minutes | About 15 to 90 minutes |
Radiation | Low dose, similar to about a year of natural background radiation | None |
Contrast dye | Iodine-based dye for a CT coronary angiogram, none for a calcium score | Often a dye injected into a vein |
Common reasons | Chest pain that could be angina | Cardiomyopathy, heart muscle damage, congenital heart disease |
What a cardiac CT scan shows
A cardiac CT scan takes a series of X-ray images that a computer turns into detailed 3D pictures of the heart and its arteries. There are two main types.
CT coronary angiogram (CTCA). Contrast dye is injected into a vein so the coronary arteries show up clearly. The scan shows whether the arteries are narrowed and whether there is fatty plaque in their walls.
Calcium score. A simpler scan without dye that measures hardened, calcified plaque and gives a number. According to the British Heart Foundation, a higher score means a higher risk of a heart attack, although it does not give detailed pictures of the arteries.
CT coronary angiography has become one of the most important tests in cardiology. NICE guidance on chest pain recommends it as a first-line test for many people whose chest pain could be angina, because it can rule coronary artery disease in or out without an invasive procedure.
Is the radiation from a heart CT safe?
The British Heart Foundation describes the dose from a cardiac CT as low, similar to the background radiation a person is naturally exposed to over a year. The NHS says there is a very small chance that radiation from X-rays can cause cancer, which is why doctors only recommend a scan when the benefit outweighs that risk. CT is not usually offered during pregnancy. If you are worried about repeated exposure, it helps to understand how often a CT scan can safely be repeated.
The contrast dye used for a CTCA is not suitable for everyone. The British Heart Foundation lists advanced kidney problems, severe asthma and a known allergy to the dye as reasons it may not be appropriate, which is why a blood test to check kidney function is sometimes needed beforehand.
What a cardiac MRI shows
A cardiac MRI builds images using a high-powered magnet and radio waves. As Royal Papworth Hospital's patient guide explains, it does not use ionising radiation, which makes it useful when someone needs repeated scans over time.
Where CT excels at the arteries, MRI excels at the heart muscle. The British Heart Foundation lists the conditions it helps to assess.
Cardiomyopathy, where the heart muscle becomes thickened, stretched or stiff.
Damage to the heart muscle after a heart attack or in heart failure.
Congenital heart disease.
Reduced blood supply to the heart muscle, using a stress MRI.
Heart tumours, which are rare.
The British Heart Foundation also lists cardiac MRI among the tests used when doctors suspect myocarditis, inflammation of the heart muscle.
What a cardiac MRI is like
You lie on a table that slides into a large, tunnel-shaped scanner. The NHS notes that MRI scanners make loud bangs and clicks, so you are given earplugs or headphones. For a heart scan you will usually be asked to hold your breath for short periods while images are taken, and stickers on your chest connect you to an ECG so the pictures can be timed to your heartbeat.
Most people with a pacemaker or implantable defibrillator can now have an MRI, but the British Heart Foundation stresses that the device must be checked first. Always tell the team about any implant, clip or metal fragment in your body.
Which scan will I need?
Most people with a heart symptom will not start with either. The usual first steps are an ECG and an echocardiogram, an ultrasound of the heart that shows the chambers, valves and pumping strength without radiation. The choice between CT and MRI usually comes after that.
Chest pain on exertion or suspected angina. A CT coronary angiogram is usually the most useful scan.
Breathlessness with an abnormal echocardiogram. An MRI may be used to look more closely at the heart muscle.
A family history of cardiomyopathy or sudden cardiac death. MRI is often part of the assessment.
Chest pain after a viral illness. MRI may be used to look for myocarditis.
Assessing overall future risk. A calcium score can add information alongside a risk calculation.
In our experience, a CT coronary angiogram works better than an MRI as the first scan for chest pain that could be angina because it looks directly at the coronary arteries and is the test NICE recommends first for many of these patients, while MRI answers different questions about the heart muscle. Sending someone for the wrong scan first can mean a second scan, a second wait and a second bill.
Echocardiograms and nuclear scans are also part of the picture, and each of the different types of heart scan answers a slightly different question.
How Heartsure arranges heart scans
From working with patients since 2012, we've kept the choice of scan with a consultant cardiologist, who reviews your symptoms and earlier results before deciding which test will answer the question. At Heartsure, a new self-funded consultation costs £250, and most first-line tests are carried out on site at our Kingston clinic, including ECGs and a transthoracic echocardiogram (£450). We also carry out myocardial perfusion scans at the clinic, a nuclear scan that shows blood flow to the heart muscle.
Our CT coronary angiograms (£990 self-funded) are performed in the radiology department at Kingston Hospital, a short distance from our clinic. Patients are asked to avoid caffeine on the day, are usually in the scanner for no more than 15 to 20 minutes, and may be observed afterwards while their heart rate and blood pressure are checked. Where needed, findings can be discussed at Kingston Hospital's CT angiogram multidisciplinary meeting, which includes specialists from St George's, St Thomas' and the Royal Brompton.
If your consultant decides a cardiac MRI is the right test, they will arrange it and review the results with you, so the decision about what happens next stays with the same specialist.
Preparing for either scan
Bring a full list of your medicines, including inhalers and anything bought over the counter.
Tell the team about any allergies, especially to contrast dye, and any kidney problems.
For CT, avoid caffeine on the day, as it raises your heart rate and makes the images harder to read.
For MRI, mention any implant, pacemaker, surgical clip or metal work history, and leave jewellery at home.
If you are pregnant or could be, tell the team before either scan.
Talk to a cardiologist about the right scan
CT and MRI are complementary rather than competing scans. CT is fast and the best way to look at the coronary arteries, while MRI is radiation free and the best way to look at the heart muscle. The right choice depends on your symptoms, your echocardiogram and what your cardiologist needs to rule in or out.
Heartsure has provided cardiology care in Kingston upon Thames since 2012, with seven consultant cardiologists and most tests available on site. Contact us to book a consultation and find out which heart scan is right for you.
